Hawaii vs. Bahamas: Which Destination Should You Visit?

Choosing between the Bahamas and Hawaii? Not the easiest choice, right? These two destinations are breathtaking, but each has its own vibe. We think the two most important things to take into account before you decide are the location and your vacation style.

Location: If you’re on the West Coast, Hawaii might be more convenient, while the Bahamas is far easier to reach from the East Coast.

Vacation Style: The Bahamas is the ultimate relaxation haven with its world-famous beaches and crystal-clear waters. Hawaii, on the other hand, is a playground for adventure seekers. It boasts towering mountains and volcanoes and it’s renowned for its surfing culture.

But, there are also other considerations, like weather, culture, cuisine, nightlife, and budget. To help you in your decision, we’ve done the homework for you, so you can focus on the fun part — deciding which sounds better for you and booking your flight and hotel.

Your Starting Point Matters!

Hawaii is just a hop away if you live on the West Coast. Its central Pacific location means shorter flights (often direct ones) and minimal time zone changes.

If you’re on the East Coast, flying to the Bahamas is cheaper and more convenient. Located in the Atlantic Ocean, it’s closer to the eastern U.S., meaning shorter flights and plenty of direct flight options.

When Are You Going?

Hawaii and the Bahamas showcase their finest weather in different seasons.

Hawaii’s weather is at its best from April to September. During these months, there’s little rain, so it’s probably the better option for a summer or early fall vacation. In contrast, the Bahamas has no rain from December to April, so it’s the ideal winter or spring getaway.

When it comes to how hot it gets, the Bahamas takes the lead. Summer temperatures in the Bahamas go as high as 90°F (32.2°C), while Hawaii’s summer temperatures are slightly cooler, reaching up to 85°F (29.4°C). Surprisingly, the warmest time in Hawaii is during the fall, when the temperatures can reach up to 87°F (30.6°C).

Diverse Landscapes, Tailored Escapes

Hawaii and the Bahamas offer a different experience.

Hawaii is all about adrenaline-pumping fun, as its mountains, rainforests, waterfalls, and four active volcanoes offer a variety of adventures. The destination was even featured in Jurassic Park! The highest point in Hawaii is a hikers’ dream come true, a towering 13,803ft (4,207m), while the waves at Waimea Bay reach 50ft (15m) in the winter, attracting surfers from all around the world.

The Bahamas, on the other hand, is all about beach and water activities. With 700 islands, there are almost endless options for stunning beaches and five-star resorts. When it comes to underwater adventures, the Bahamas is world-renowned. The Andros Barrier Reef, located near the Bahamian coast, is the third largest living organism on Earth. It’s a haven for snorkelers and divers, boasting more than 164 unique fish and coral species.

Later we share some activity ideas in “Fun Things to Do”, so make sure to check out that section to get the full picture of the activities available to you in both destinations.

Nightlife Is a Blast

Hawaii and the Bahamas don’t have the wild nightlife scenes of Miami or Cancun, but they’re far from boring. Both destinations offer plenty of fun for your nights out, so there’s no winner in this category.

Hawaii offers its share of cafes, bars, and nightclubs where you can drink a cocktail and enjoy karaoke or live music. Among the Hawaiian islands, Oahu is the most lively at nighttime, specifically the area of Honolulu, Chinatown, and Waikiki.

For a taste of the Bahamian nightlife, head to Nassau. The capital city keeps the party going with plenty of bars, nightclubs, and casinos that stay open well into the night. You’ll find most of the action along the downtown area and Paradise Island.

A Taste of Culture

Both Hawaii and the Bahamas have captivating but distinct cultures, but we’d say that Hawaii’s got a bit more commercial flair.

In Hawaii, everything revolves around “Aloha,” and you’ll feel it right from the start. Aloha means love, peace, kindness, and unity, and it’s their way of saying “hello.” When you arrive at the airport or hotel, Hawaiians give you a welcoming lei, a flower necklace symbolizing their hospitality. They have a traditional dance called Hula, and their music includes instruments like the ukulele and slack-key guitar. If you’ve watched movies like “Lilo & Stitch” and “Moana,” you’ve already had a peek into this lively culture.

In the Bahamas, the culture is rich but more understated. While most people visit the Bahamas for the stunning scenery, there’s a cultural side to this location too, and music is a big part of it. There’s a vibrant street parade festival called Junkanoo, which happens on Boxing Day (December 26) and New Year’s Day, and it’s where you’ll see Bahamian culture on full display. You’ll see the locals wearing lively traditional costumes and hear their well-known music, rake and scrape, calypso, and goombay. Another Bahamian cultural trademark that you’ll notice when walking down the street is their intricate straw work, like baskets, hats, and bags, made from natural materials like palm fronds and sisal.

Two Unique Culinary Journeys

Hawaii boasts greater culinary diversity, while the Bahamas excels in seafood cuisine.

Hawaiian cuisine is a fusion of Asian, Pacific, and indigenous influences. You’ll find dishes like “poke” (raw fish salad), sushi, “malasadas” (Portuguese donuts), and “loco moco” (Portuguese sausage with rice and eggs). You’ll have the chance to try traditional Hawaiian dishes like “poi” (mashed taro root), “lomi lomi Salmon” (diced salmon with tomatoes and onions), “kalua pig” (slow-roasted, shredded pork), “lau lau” (steamed meat or fish wrapped in taro or luau leaves), and desserts like “haupia” (coconut pudding). Hawaii is also known for its Kona coffee, grown on the slopes of the Mauna Loa volcano, so don’t miss out on a cup in the morning!

Bahamian cuisine, on the other hand, is a delightful blend of African, Caribbean, and European influences. While Hawaii is much more diversified in terms of flavors, Bahamian cuisine puts a strong emphasis on local seafood like conch, grouper, snapper, mahi-mahi, and more. Apart from seafood, you’ll find traditional Bahamian dishes like “souse” (chicken/pork soup), Johnny cake (sweet/sour fried bread), and the delectable “guava duff” dessert (steamed dumpling or cake with guava). The Bahamas also has a larger number of fast food chains compared to Hawaii to cater to tourist taste.

Price Tag: Hawaii Might be the More Budget-Friendly Choice

Traveling to Hawaii or the Bahamas can be a bit expensive, but when we crunched the numbers, it turned out thatHawaii is the more budget-friendly choice compared to the Bahamas.

If you’re considering a trip to Hawaii, you can expect to spend approximately $1,780 to $3,850 for a one-week adventure. That’s an average of $550 to $1,350 for an economy class flight ticket, around $120 to $170 per night for a 2 or 3-star hotel room, and roughly $74 to $150 per day for various expenses including transportation, tours, and food.

On the other hand, if you were to visit the Bahamas, you should expect to spend around $1,850 to $3,750 for a one-week trip. This budget covers a flight ticket in the ballpark of $380 to $750 for economy class, accommodations at a 2 or 3-star hotel costing about $120 to $130 per night, and daily expenses for food, transportation, and activities, which might run you about $100 to $220 per day.

Bonus tip: Book your vacation during the off-season when you can find hotel and airfare deals for as much as 60% off. This way, you can spend about the same in the Bahamas as you would in Hawaii. Having an estimate of your travel expenses is helpful, but it’s even better when you know when to score a great deal.

Hawaii vs Bahamas: Full Activity Breakdown

Hawaii: Adventure Junkies Wonderland

• Check out Hawaii Volcanoes National Park on the Big Island to see active volcanoes and lava flows
• Climb to the top of Diamond Head Crater on Oahu for awesome views of Waikiki and the ocean
• Dive into Hanauma Bay on Oahu, Molokini Crater near Maui, or Kealakekua Bay on the Big Island to meet colorful marine life
• Fly above Hawaii’s breathtaking landscapes on a helicopter ride
• Join a surf lesson in Waikiki
• Visit the historic Lahaina town on Maui
• Snorkel with sea turtles at Turtle Town in Maui
• Join a whale-watching tour to get up close and personal with humpback whales
• Explore the Japanese Byodo-In Temple in the Valley of the Temples on Oahu
• Get close to sharks in their natural habitat with a cage-diving adventure on Oahu’s North Shore
• Hike the trails around Waipio Valley on the Big Island, and try cliff jumping into a refreshing waterhole
• Zip through rainforests, like the Kapalua Zipline on Maui
• Take an ATV tour through rugged terrain
• Glide above Hawaii’s landscapes with a paraglider
• Ride with a mountain bike through the challenging downhill trails of Kohala Mountain on the Big Island.
• Speed across clear Hawaiian waters on a jet ski
• Skydive over Hawaii’s stunning scenery, with drop zones on Oahu and the Big Island

Bahamas: Sun, Sand & Everything Ocean-Nice

• Go on a boat trip and swim with cute pigs at Pig Beach
• Walk around Nassau, shop at the Straw Market, and check out Fort Fincastle and Fort Charlotte
• Dive and see amazing marine life on the Andros Barrier Reef
• Try fun water activities like kayaking and paddleboarding
• Explore the mysterious natural formation of Dean’s Blue Hole on Long Island
• Find neat spots to swim, like the Queen’s Staircase in Nassau or the boiling holes on Eleuthera
• Learn about pirates at the Pirates of Nassau Museum
• Get souvenirs and local crafts at markets
• Swim with the dolphins on Blue Lagoon Island
• Play golf on awesome courses like Ocean Club Golf Course
• Visit wildlife sanctuaries like the Ardastra Gardens and Wildlife Conservation Centre in Nassau
• Take guided tours and taste locally made rums

FAQ

We also put together a list of answers to some common queries that might make it easier for you to make your decision.

The Takeaways

Here’s the scoop:

Hawaii: Get ready for adventure! Explore mountains, rainforests, waterfalls, and volcanoes. You’ll literally feel like you’re in the Jurassic Park movie. Hikers, you’ve got a 4,207-meter peak to conquer. Surfers, get ready to ride the 50-foot waves at Waimea Bay.

Bahamas: Beautiful beaches and water fun await! With 700 islands, you’ll find endless beaches and top-notch resorts. If you love snorkeling and diving, the Andros Barrier Reef is your dream spot. It’s the third-largest living thing on Earth, full of amazing fish and corals.

Culture: Hawaii tends to offer a more authentic travel experience. In contrast, the Bahamas might feel a bit more tourist-oriented, especially when there are no major festivals taking place.

Food: If you’re looking for culinary diversity, Hawaii will capture your heart, while if you’re a seafood enthusiast, the Bahamas is the destination for you.

Price: Both destinations are pricey, however, Hawaii is the cheaper option out of the two.

We hope we’ve made your decision-making easier. Happy travels!

---